Connecting Genres:
To Kill a Mockingbird Harper Lee
Alex Jefferson Marsh
While reading “To Kill a Mockingbird” I began to think about the depiction of racial and intellectual inequity in different genres. While the struggles Tom Robinson endured in the Deep South seem like material that has been covered well and often, I was surprised how easily I came up with disparate titles in different formats that all dealt with characters who struggled with similar issues at about the same time. The following texts helped me to focus on th racial inequality which Lee brings to light in her novel:
“Big River”
“Native Son” by Richard Wright
“Sanford and Son” starring Redd Foxx
“X” directed by Spike Lee
However, on top of the issues I saw as Atticus Finch tried to defend Robinson, I also saw the phenomenon of intellecctual bigotry raised its ugly head. Jem and Scout create a would-be monster of Boo Radley, although the fear of him is forgotten when he saves the lives of the children. Regardless, however, the prejudice which Boo suffers from the entire town show how people with lowered cognitive functioning are often equally spurned by polite society in exactly the same fashion which people of different races are. Thinking about this I came up with a list of works that dealt with mental illness in the South:
“Ballad of the Sad Cafe,” by Carson McCullers
“As I Lay Dying,” by William Faulkner
“Native Son,” by Richard Wright
“Of Mice and Men,” John Steinbeck
“A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner
I think the topic is fascinating and gives both the cultural norms and expectations around Boo Radley’s characters as well as providing insight into the mind of the mentally handicapped southerner as well. In particular, I like how all the works take place in a time frame around the Great Depression. The combination of both temporal and thematic unity between these works leads to some fantastic inter-textual cross-reading. Here’s a text-by-text breakdown:
As I Lay Dying, William Faulkner, Vintage Publishing, 1930
Faulkner’s fascination with point of view and mental illness continue with this account of a family’s journey to bury their matriarch. One of the children of the dead mother is mentally disabled and is coming to grips with the concept of death at the same time that the rest of the family is coming to grips with life without Addie. This is both southern lit AND a coming of age tale, the prose is accessible and the book is not terribly long. Students should be able to read excepts from the story alongside the final chapters of To Kill a Mockingbird and gain new insight into Arthur and his mother’s relationship.
Of Mice and Men, John Steinbeck, Penguin 1937.
The story of Lenny and George has been immortalized in film and in the mythos of Americana – it has even made its way as the inspiration of Bugs Bunny’s abominable snowman. Often the image of the two drifters is synonymous with the difficulties facing Americans during the great depression. Like Boo Radley, Lenny is faced with murder, however he is not protected by the people of the town the way that Boo was. Instead Lenny is a man without a country, his only companion the ever-worried George. Students could get a real insight into the importance of the final conversation between Atticus Finch and the sheriff of Maycomb when put beside excepts from Steinbeck’s novel. By understanding the desperate times of the Great Depression along with the stigma of mental illness the students could get a better understanding of what it meant to be Arthur Radley
Native Son, by Richard Wright, Harper 1940
While Bigger Thomas, the main character of Wright’s novel, is not officially deemed to be suffering from a mental disability, his decisions and his actions suggest that he was operating at the lower end of the intelligence curve. What is important about Wright’s depiction of Bigger is the same thing that makes Of Mice and Men so compelling: we are dealing with a mentally impaired killer during the depression. While Steinbeck’s account is largely of the agrarian mid-West, and deals with the white experience, Wright’s prose is guided towards the black experience. Suddenly the law system, the courtroom drama that surrounds Tom Robinson’s accusations can be seen from the perspective of a man who really did commit a crime. Native Son provides an opportunity for students to see not only how impaired thinking can affect a character, but also how racism and poverty can affect decision-making.
“Ballad of the Sad Cafe,” by Carson McCullers, Mariner, 1951
When Amelia, the protagonist of McCuller’s short story, meets the hunchbacked Cousin Lymon the meeting changes her life, briefly, for the better. And yet despite the easy early goings the story ends tragically when her original husband returns from prison. Cousin Lymon is a sympathetic character very similar to Boo Radley – doing kindness to the people in his world despite his genetic shortcomings. Students can compare and contrast the differences in McCuller’s love story and Lee’s coming-of-age tale. The semblances between Boo and Lymon are strong, both in terms of being people who are shunned by traditional society as well as their desire to do good. In addition, both stories take place in the Great Depression South. Given all the similarities in setting and time, students should be able to identify key differences within their similarity and hopefuly come up with a more learned interpretation of Harper Lee’s definitive work.
“A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner, The Forum, 1930
Although I am supplying the short story for the bibliography I will be discussing the play version of the story. Emily Grierson has been living at home with only her servant helping her to run the affairs of the house. Homer Baron, her boyfriend of years earlier, had never been heard from when their relationship went south. However, the story of murder and small-town life in the South during the Great Depression are as pertinent in Faulkner’s tale as they are in Lee’s. In particular, the dealings of the local authorities, whether they be the Maycomb sheriff refusing to acknowledge Boo’s involvement in the death of Mr. Ewell, or the city counsil deciding not to charge Emily Grierson any taxes, are remarkably similar. Hopefully students could recognize the similarities in setting for the story and the macabre developments of Emily’s love life could reflect the fascination which Jem and Scout hold for Boo Radley.